Grades for Chiefs' offseason reset, from free agency haul to Taylor Swift aura

The Kansas City Chiefs entered the 2025 NFL season hoping to become the first team to earn a Super Bowl three-peat.

Instead, they sputtered to their worst-ever finish during Andy Reid's 13 seasons in Kansas City.

The Chiefs posted just a 6-11 record in a season that was marred by a bevy offensive issues that led to the team struggle badly in one-score contests. Kansas City lost starting quarterback Patrick Mahomes to a torn ACL and LCL in his left knee in the game during which it was eliminated from playoff contention, adding injury to what was already an insulting season.

As such, Kansas City entered the offseason hoping for two things: get healthy and reshape its roster to better support Mahomes, especially with him returning from a significant injury.

Were the Chiefs able to accomplish those goals? Here's a complete breakdown of Kansas City's offseason and whether the team has the talent and pathway needed to be a contender in 2026.

Kansas City Chiefs offseason report card

Free agency: C

Free agency was a mixed bag for the Chiefs. On the one hand, they made a notable upgrade to their running game by signing Kenneth Walker to replace Isiah Pacheco and Kareem Hunt. The Super Bowl 60 MVP should help take pressure off Mahomes, which could prove critical as the 31-year-old quarterback returns from his significant knee injury.

However, the Chiefs also lost a lot of talent, particularly on defense. Notably, they lost three starters from their secondary, as cornerback Jaylen Watson and safety Bryan Cook signed with the Rams and Bengals in free agency while star cornerback Trent McDuffie was traded to the Rams.

That overhaul, along with the loss of linebacker Leo Chenal, could prove a lot for the Chiefs to overcome on defense even after adding some solid veteran depth in the form of defensive tackle Khyiris Tonga, safety Alohi Gilman and CB L'Jarius Sneed.

NFL draft: B+

The good news for the Chiefs? They had a rock-solid 2026 NFL Draft that helped shore up their defense. Kansas City spent its first three picks on that side of the ball, landing the draft's top cornerback, Mansoor Delane, a potential-packed defensive tackle in Peter Woods and an explosive, high-motor edge rusher in R Mason Thomas.

The Chiefs also spent a seventh-round selection on quarterback Garrett Nussmeier – viewed by many as a Day 2 talent – after he slid due to injury. Having him to develop behind Mahomes and free-agent signee Justin Fields will be nice for Reid.

State of the roster: B-

This version of the Chiefs has more concerns than previous iterations. The cornerback group is particularly suspect, though Delane's presence raises that unit's ceiling. Elsewhere, the team is thinner than most would like at receiver while right tackle remains a question mark.

Still, Mahomes remains one of the NFL's best quarterbacks even with the questions facing him in his return. Kansas City's interior offensive line remains strong thanks to the Creed Humphrey and Trey Smith pairing while Rashee Rice and Xavier Worthy could be a strong receiver duo, if all goes well.

Defensively, the Chiefs still look strong up the middle thanks to Chris Jones and the team's newly-acquired interior depth as well as the Nick Bolton and Drue Tranquill partnership at linebacker. It's just a matter of whether they will be able to hold up in coverage with their new-look secondary.

All that's to say that while the Chiefs still have an above-average roster, it has far more holes than many of its recent Super Bowl-winning units have.

Chance of contending in 2026: B

There are some factors working against the Chiefs this season. They play in the AFC West, which figures to once again be one of the toughest divisions in football, and will need to stay afloat early in the season either without Mahomes or with him still getting his injured left leg under him.

Kansas City is also undergoing a lot of changes on defense, so it may take a while before Steve Spagnuolo's unit is playing at its peak.

Still, there's plenty of evidence to suggest that Reid and Co. will be able to turn this team into a playoff contender once again. He and Mahomes have three rings together, after all.

Long-term outlook and team direction: A-

The Chiefs still have a rosy outlook long-term. Realistically, that will remain as long as the Reid-Mahomes partnership is in effect. Sure, the team will have to get creative with its finances considering the quarterback's record-breaking contract, but GM Brett Veach has shown an ability to navigate the cap well across his tenure.

This offseason is a great example of that. Veach had to play "Moneyball" with some portion of the team's roster as expenses mounted, and he chose the secondary for that. That was an astute move considering Spagnuolo's penchant for developing defensive back talent, and giving him a top prospect like Delane via a trade up was a sensible maneuver.

The biggest questions with which Kansas City will soon reckon are about how to replace Travis Kelce and whether to extend Rashee Rice. As long as they find suitable answers to those and fill any holes that develop during the 2026 season, the Chiefs should remain a contender.

Aura and vibes: B

Vibes around the Chiefs are generally good. Mahomes' recovery from his late-season injury has inspired optimism, as he and the team has posted videos of him working out and throwing, while the antics surrounding Kelce's wedding to Taylor Swift showed off the team's strong-looking bond.

The lone negative? Rice has had a trying offseason during which he spent time in jail for a probation violation. Questions about his ability to stay on the field continue to persist, and he remains one of the team's biggest short- and long-term question marks because of it.

Nonetheless, there seems to be a lot of belief that the Chiefs can re-establish themselves as a playoff contender during the 2026 NFL season. That's great news for a team that endured a disappointing and shocking 6-11 campaign last year after back-to-back Super Bowl wins.

Overall offseason grade: B-

It's hard to fault the Chiefs too much for the approach they took during the offseason. They suffered some key losses in free agency, but that was to be expected given how much they are paying to Mahomes and other stars on the roster.

Kansas City should still be a playoff contender, but questions remain whether this year's iteration of the team can reach the Super Bowl ceiling of previous squads. It's hard to categorically count out Mahomes and Reid, but given the holes Kansas City has, it wouldn't be a surprise to see it have to scratch and claw its way into the playoff race.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Grades for Chiefs' offseason reset, from free agency haul to Taylor Swift aura