Everton’s Full Backs Evaluated: A 2025-26 Season Summary

As the 2025-26 season wraps up, it’s time to assess the performance of Everton's full backs, highlighting their strengths and areas for improvement. There is an urgent need for enhancements at right back and additional support for Vitaliy Mykolenko on the left flank, a recurring theme in previous reviews. With summer transfer plans on the horizon, fans hope for swift action to alleviate these concerns.

Vitaliy Mykolenko had a commendable season, appearing in 36 matches, during which he recorded one assist and received six yellow cards. The Ukrainian defender excelled in his defensive duties, ranking highly in interceptions, clearances, and aerial duels within the Premier League. However, his offensive contributions were lacking, with minimal involvement in creating scoring opportunities. With only one significant chance created throughout the season, his attacking output falls considerably short of expectations. Mykolenko recently signed a contract extension, securing his place at Everton until June 2029, but questions remain about his future role, especially if there’s a coaching change.

Seamus Coleman, Everton's club captain, has seen his playing time diminish significantly as he enters his late thirties. This season, he participated in just three league matches, totaling 196 minutes across all competitions. Despite his reduced on-field presence, Coleman remains a respected figure and is still active internationally with Ireland. His future remains uncertain, with speculation about potential moves to various clubs, as he has yet to announce his retirement. Regardless of his next steps, Coleman will always be celebrated as a club legend for his unwavering dedication.

Nathan Patterson, who joined the club in January 2022, faced a challenging season marred by injuries, limiting him to eight appearances. Despite being a young talent with promise, he has struggled to find consistent playing time under manager David Moyes. Interestingly, Patterson was called up to the Scotland national team for the upcoming World Cup, which could provide him with a platform to showcase his abilities. With Coleman’s impending retirement, the club must decide whether to invest in Patterson’s development or seek new options at right back as the summer transfer window approaches.