Arizona Diamondbacks 6, San Francisco Giants 2: Win Ugly

Record: 29-24. Pace: 89-73. Change on 2025: +3.

The Diamondbacks won the opening game of their series in San Francisco this afternoon. The win moved them into sole possession of the third wild-card in the National League, and was their eighth victory in the last nine games. It was, looking at the final result, quite comfortable. After Ketel Marte’s single drove in a pair in the sixth to complete the scoring, the team’s Win Probability was never less than 92.6%. But, sheesh. This was a win only its mother could love, with the D-backs sloppy on both offense and defense, capped off with a “Not seen that before” moment from Marte. On the other hand, if you can have so much room for improvement, and still get the W, maybe that’s a good thing?

Largely devoid of blame in the above is Merrill Kelly, who posted his fourth quality start in a row. As mentioned in the preview, these haven’t exactly come against the strongest of opponents. Still, he’s got it done as a good pitcher should. Today, he gave Arizona seven innings of two-run ball, on four hits and two walks, with five strikeouts. Kelly is 5-0 against teams currently below .500, and 0-3 facing teams above .500. The only real static came in the bottom of the fourth inning. It began after the Diamondbacks ran out of challenges, Gabriel Moreno wasting our second, after Nolan Arenado had blown one in the second inning. The batter ended up walking.

This was followed by a pair of doubles over the head of Corbin Carroll, which might have been outs: the first in particular was in and out of his glove. [These weren’t our only misplays either. The first batter in the game for San Francisco singled in front of Ryan Waldschmidt, after he had initially broken back on the ball.] They scored a pair of runs, giving the Giants a 2-1 lead. I am also under strict instructions to tell you that Rafael Devers is now Mrs. SnakePit’s most hated player for his “disgusting” chewing and spitting habits, which almost provoked a Roman moment in SnakePit Towers. Googling tells me it’s not tobacco… But Mrs. S is far from convinced.

Anyway. That was it for the Giants offense, though they had their chances, as our bullpen wobbled but held. Jonathan Loaisiga gave up a lead-off double, then retired the next three batters in the eighth. Then Brandyn Garcia triggered indigestion in the ninth by hitting the first batter he faced, then going 3-0 on the next. A much needed double-play calmed the nerves, and he got the final out to move Arizona back to five above .500, tying our season high set on April 18 at 13-8. We haven’t been beyond that since the end of 2024, so it’d be nice if the team can keep up its momentum here.

The offense was good enough. Though it felt like there were any number of wasted opportunities across the course of the game. Gabriel Moreno got Arizona on the board in the third inning, with his third home-run of the season (above). The D-backs had a chance to add on there, getting one-out singles from Tommy Troy, Marte and Carroll. But Geraldo Perdomo struck out without taking the bat off his shoulder, and Nolan Arenado fouled out. Fortunately, the Giants were playing just as sloppily as the Diamondbacks, and a pair of defensive mistakes by them opened the door to a three-run fifth inning, giving Arizona a lead they’d not relinquish.

It began with Troy reaching second on a wild throw from Willy Adames. Marte then blooped a pitch just in front of left-fielder Casey Schmitt, who opted to ignore the ball as it went past him. Somehow, this was scored an RBI double, but Marte will take it. Perdomo then singled Ketel home, and after an Arenado ground-out moved Perdomo into scoring position, Adrian Del Castillo made it 4-2 to Arizona. Marte then got another hit in the sixth, driving in Moreno, who’d walked, and Jose Fernandez, who had doubled. And Marte wasn’t done either, getting his fourth hit of the game… while still making the out at first.

This came in the seventh, on our most annoying (yet, I’ll admit it, amusing enough – albeit, only because we won anyway) gaffe of the season. Troy walked, and Marte sent a fly-ball down the first-base line. It clanked out of the right fielder’s glove, and Marte hared round first, intending to reach second. Unfortunately, he met Troy, who was still intent on returning to first-base (above). While both realized their error, ending up on first and second, the Giants appealed, and on review, Marte was ruled to have passed Troy and so was out. It was reminiscent of this play back in 2018, when Deven Marrero was robbed of what would have been his only HR with us, for a similar base-running mistake.

In the end, it proved irrelevant – mostly because of the Giants going 1-for-8 with runners in scoring position, otherwise it would likely have been a lot more nervewracking. But we got there. Marte finished the day with four more hits. He now has a nine-game hitting streak where he is 21-for-37 – that’s an average of .568 – with three home-runs and 15 RBI. He got help today from Carroll’s two hits, while Del Castillo, Moreno and Troy each chipped in with a hit and a walk. The only starter not to reach base this afternoon was Ryan Waldschmidt, who had a rough 0-for-5 day with a trio of strikeouts.

Click here for details, at Fangraphs.com
Memorialized: Ketel Marte, +23%
Well remembered: Del Castillo, +13%; Moreno, +11%
Best forgotten: Nolan Arenado, -11%

Thanks to all who showed up in the Gameday Thread on this Memorial Day. 330 comments is very respectable, I’d say. I’m declaring Comment of the Thread a tie between MikeMono and AZNailgal520:

We will be back tomorrow at the same park, to face the Giants again. It will be a 6:45 pm first pitch, the only night game of the series, with the mound being taken by Arizona staff ace Eduardo Rodriguez. And, yeah, it does still feel funny writing that, thank you for asking…